Normally, I would just use the gluten-free Bisquick mix, but if I'm going to commit to this Julie/Julia idea of mine, I gotta try it out.
But this recipe turned into a really interesting dilemma. It wasn't a home run hit like the rest of the recipes that I've have had. So... let the battle begin!
1. Preparation- Bisquick
Does this seem like a surprise? With Bisquick, it's dump the mix out, pour in the milk and oil, add the eggs and badabing badaboom. Done.
Meanwhile with ATK, separate your dry from your wet (except sugar went with the dry)-
A phrase which here means a lot of extra steps.Meanwhile with ATK, separate your dry from your wet (except sugar went with the dry)-
This is me, mixing really fast... with one hand... while I take a photo |
2. Flavor- ATK
This time, I've got to give a slight edge to ATK's waffles. Both have a good flavor, but ATK has almost a nuttiness to the batter. Don't ask me where that came from! Maybe it's the brown rice flour? Bisquick has a very light almost tasteless taste. (A tasteless taste?...) The buttermilk helped ATK's batter with a little extra tang- not tangy, but definitely not watery.
3. Texture/Fluffiness- Bisquick
Now, if you want a fluffy light waffle, hands down, go with Bisquick. As a batter, I thought it just wouldn't rise, but put it on the waffle iron and watch it rise to its fluffy airy goodness. ATK has a thick batter. I was mixing and mixing that batter to make sure there were no lumps. (Yes, I put my phone down to mix it.) If you like a thicker, heartier waffle, then ATK's waffles are for you! They have substance and easily fill you up. I'm really glad that I had bananas to eat with this. Those waffles were heavy! Without the bananas, I would've dropped into the apartment below me.
4. Longevity- Bisquick
This is a no-brainer, unfortuately. Bisquick waffles behave like those with regular flour. After a while, they soften from the steam and being stacked on top of each other, but a toaster does well to fix that moistness. Sure, if they're left out too long, they get stiff too. But ATK, I'm prrrrrreeetty sure that just goes straight to the stiff stage. You get a very heavy frisbee if you don't eat that up quickly.
Overall, Bisquick wins this waffle war. I might come back to this recipe later to try it again to see if it wasn't something I did (e.g. using a hand or stand alone mixer instead of hand whisking it). It just goes to show that cooking is a science, and the slightest of changes affect everything.